The Freight Fraud Report
Cargo theft and freight fraud are at an all-time high. Here's what the data actually looks like — and what every broker needs to know to stay protected.
Sources: CargoNet, FreightWaves, NICB, FBI UCR, FMCSA, BSI Supply Chain Services
$436M+
Cargo stolen in H1 2026 alone
CargoNet — on pace to shatter all previous annual records
2,400+
Incidents projected for 2026
Based on H1 2026 pace — up from 1,778 in 2023
$125,548
Average loss per incident
Strategic thefts average $664,000+ per event
89%
Incidents go unreported
Industry estimate — most carriers absorb losses quietly
The Surge Is Getting Worse Every Year
Cargo theft has more than tripled since 2018. The 2026 H1 figure of $436M already exceeds every full-year loss total before 2023 — and the year is only half over.
2018
$97M
losses
2019
$118M
losses
2020
$129M
losses
2021
$155M
losses
2022
$168M
losses
2023
$223M
losses
2024
$312M
losses
2025
$378M
losses
2026*
$436M
H1 only
* 2026 reflects H1 data only (CargoNet). Full-year projected at 2,400+ incidents and $800M+ in losses.
How Freight Fraud Happens
Not all freight fraud looks the same. Here's how incidents break down by type — and which categories are growing fastest.
Strategic/Fictitious Pickup
Fraudulent carriers impersonate legitimate ones, pick up loads, and disappear. Average loss: $664K per event.
34%
+112% YoYDouble Brokering
A broker re-brokers a load without authorization, pocketing the freight payment while leaving the shipper exposed.
28%
+89% YoYCargo Theft (In Transit)
Loads stolen while in transit — often at truck stops, rest areas, or unsecured drop yards.
22%
+41% YoYIdentity Theft / Carrier Impersonation
Fraudsters clone legitimate MC numbers, DOT numbers, and carrier identities to pass FMCSA checks.
10%
+203% YoYCargo Shortage / Pilferage
Partial theft — loads arrive short, with seals intact. Often an inside job or driver-level theft.
6%
+8% YoYGeographic Hotspots
Cargo theft is heavily concentrated. Five states account for nearly two-thirds of all reported incidents.
Most Targeted Commodities
What thieves go after depends on resale value and ease of liquidation. Pharmaceuticals carry the highest average loss per incident.
Food & Beverage
Avg loss: $48,200
Electronics
Avg loss: $312,000
Metals & Building Materials
Avg loss: $67,400
Household Goods
Avg loss: $41,800
Pharmaceuticals
Avg loss: $891,000
Clothing & Apparel
Avg loss: $38,600
Auto Parts
Avg loss: $55,200
Other
Avg loss: Varies
Numbers That Should Keep You Up at Night
Behind every statistic is a broker who didn't see it coming. These facts put the scale of the problem in perspective.
3 minutes
Average time to execute a strategic fictitious pickup — fraud moves faster than manual verification.
Friday–Sunday
62% of cargo thefts occur on weekends when carrier offices are closed and response is slower.
73%
Of stolen loads are never recovered. Once a load disappears, the odds of recovery are slim.
1 in 4
Freight brokers report being targeted by double brokering or identity fraud at least once per month.
48 hours
The critical window — most stolen cargo is moved, broken up, or sold within 48 hours of theft.
Top 5 states
CA, TX, FL, IL, and NJ account for 65% of all reported cargo theft incidents nationally.
What Brokers Can Do Right Now
Verify every carrier before tendering a load
Cross-check MC and DOT numbers against FMCSA and community watchlists — not just at onboarding, but on every single load.
Confirm driver identity at pickup
Request a photo ID and compare it against the driver name on the rate confirmation. Ghost carriers rely on brokers skipping this step.
Use real-time location check-ins
Automated driver check-ins create a verifiable chain of custody and give you early warning if a load goes dark.
Report incidents to a shared watchlist
Every unreported incident is a gift to the next fraudster. Shared community intelligence is the only way to stay ahead of repeat offenders.
Don't Be the Next Statistic
Freight 411 gives brokers real-time carrier verification, community watchlist cross-checks, and driver two-way messaging — everything you need to stay ahead of fraud.
Data sourced from CargoNet Annual Cargo Theft Report, FreightWaves, NICB, FBI UCR, FMCSA, and BSI Supply Chain Services. 2026 figures reflect H1 data only (CargoNet). Statistics reflect most recently published figures.